American
Au Cheval
Au Cheval, an import from Chicago restaurateur Brendan Sodikoff, is tucked away down Cortlandt Alley, giving it a cool, old-school New York feel. It's known for reimagining traditional American fare in a setting that evokes a Gilded Age tavern, complete with brick walls and leather banquettes. Regulars know that while reservations are available, walking in and grabbing a seat at the bar can offer a more laid-back experience.
★ The Legend
Double Cheeseburger
This burger features two prime beef patties cooked on a griddle, topped with sharp American cheddar, pickles, onions, and dijonnaise, all served on a perfectly soft brioche bun. It's celebrated for its rich, beefy flavor and the perfect balance of ingredients, often enhanced with thick-cut maple-glazed bacon and a fried egg for an extra layer of decadence.
◆ Fan Favorite
Bacon & Black Pepper Mac & Cheese
This isn't just any mac and cheese; it's described as a 'perfect Mac & Cheese and Cacio e Pepe lovechild,' featuring bits of their famous thick-cut bacon and enough black pepper to make Cacio e Pepe fans drool. It's a generously sized and addictive dish that regulars consistently rave about.
● Chef's Pick
Crispy Potato Hash with Duck Heart Gravy
This dish is frequently mentioned by critics as a standout, offering a unique and indulgent take on a diner classic, and is considered a 'two-fisted after-hours chef's favorite.'
◇ Hidden Gem
Fried House-Made Bologna Sandwich
Most first-timers overlook this, but regulars swear by the fried house-made bologna sandwich, which is super thinly sliced and fried, far from any cheap deli meat. It's a surprisingly decadent and delicious option that offers a unique texture and flavor profile.
Insider Tip
First-timers often make the mistake of only ordering the burger. While it's legendary, don't sleep on the other dishes. Order a few sides and starters to share, like the Mac & Cheese or the Fried House-Made Bologna Sandwich, to truly experience the breadth of their elevated diner fare. This way, you get a more diverse and satisfying meal beyond just the main event.
AI-generated results — always verify dishes and information before visiting.