Search any restaurant by name and city. We research the must-order dishes across critic reviews, food media, and regulars, and surface the inside knowledge most first-timers never find.
★ The LegendThe dish the restaurant is most famous for.
◆ Fan FavoriteWhat regulars reorder every single visit without thinking twice.
● Chef's PickExplicitly endorsed by the chef or kitchen.
◇ Hidden GemWhat first-timers walk past. Often a side or starter regulars always order.
Results are AI-generated and may not always be accurate. Always verify dishes and hours before visiting.
Court Street Grocers started with a vision to elevate the humble sandwich, transforming it into something truly special. Owners Eric Finkelstein and Matt Ross, art school grads with a deep love for regional American foods, opened their first shop in Carroll Gardens, creating a space that feels like a curated general store. It's a place where you can grab a meticulously crafted sandwich alongside a shelf full of nostalgic, hard-to-find pantry items, all while soaking in a friendly, neighborhood atmosphere.
★ The Legend
Italian Combo
This sandwich is a masterclass in balance, featuring mortadella, soppressata, Swiss, mozzarella, pecorino romano, arugula, white onion, CSG hoagie spread, and mayo on a seeded hero. The bread, a Caputo's hoagie roll, is specifically chosen for its 'bread cloud' texture—soft inside with a slight crunch outside—providing the perfect foundation for the flavorful fillings.
◆ Fan Favorite
Reuben
Court Street Grocers takes this classic to another level by house-curing their corned beef using short rib, which is fattier and more flavorful than traditional brisket. It's served on toasted Orwasher's rye with Swiss, sauerkraut, and their tangy, smoky homemade comeback sauce, creating a rich, cheesy, and tangy experience.
● Chef's Pick
The Brunson
This sandwich was personally selected by Knicks superstar Jalen Brunson in a DoorDash campaign, with culinary director Ted Rosen curating the ingredients to fit Brunson's preferences (no cheese, bacon, or beef). It features confit turkey, sweet potato, broccoli rabe, Mama Lil's peppers, pickled red onion, and Crystal Hot-Honey Agrodolce on Sullivan Street Bakery 'Stecca' bread.
◇ Hidden Gem
Breakfast Sandwich
While many flock for lunch, the breakfast sandwich is a standout that first-timers often overlook. It's a deceptively simple yet satisfying combination of soft scrambled eggs, sharp cheddar, and peppery arugula on a chewy Balthazar ciabatta bun. The quality of ingredients elevates this morning staple far beyond your average bodega grab.
Insider Tip
Don't just grab your sandwich and go; take a moment to explore the shelves. Court Street Grocers is renowned for its eclectic collection of regional American food products, from unique sodas to specialty condiments. You might discover a new favorite pantry item or a nostalgic treat you haven't seen in years, adding another layer to your experience beyond the incredible sandwiches.