Every restaurant has its legendary dishes. Find out exactly what to order.

Crusty Baker

📍 Maps

A kosher neighborhood bakery specializing in naturally leavened sourdough loaves and rich dairy chocolate babkas. The kitchen relies on traditional slow-fermentation techniques to achieve deeply caramelized, blistered crusts and soft, airy interiors. Because walk-ins are not accepted, you must submit your order online by Wednesday evening to secure a Friday pickup.

★ The Legend

House Sourdough

This loaf is celebrated for its exceptionally hard, blistered crust that gives way to a remarkably fluffy, moist, and airy interior. Regulars often slice it thick to make morning toasts, considering it one of the absolute best sourdoughs in the city.

◆ Fan Favorite

Dairy Chocolate Babka

This rich, buttery cake features a soft, sticky crumb heavily swirled with chocolate that sets it apart from standard dry bakery versions. Locals frequently purchase the twenty-dollar loaf as a crowd-pleasing gift for weekend dinner parties.

◇ Hidden Gem

Seeded Sourdough

This variation incorporates a dense coating of toasted seeds that adds a nutty, earthy dimension to the bakery's signature tangy crumb. Devotees make a point of reserving this specific loaf alongside their weekly staples to ensure they do not miss out.

Insider Tip

While the name is often associated with Brooklyn-based food markets and pop-ups, the actual brick-and-mortar storefront for this beloved British-style bakery is located in Kemptville, Ontario, where they bake their signature breads and pastries daily.

Every restaurant has its legendary dishes.

Find what to order anywhere →

AI-generated results — always verify dishes and information before visiting.

How it works

Crusty Baker