Order this.
Order this.

Every restaurant has its legendary dishes. Find out exactly what to order.

Search a restaurant →
Italian

Eataly NYC Flatiron

Flatiron District, Manhattan, NY 📍 Maps

Eataly was born from Oscar Farinetti's vision to bring high-quality Italian food to everyone, transforming a former vermouth factory in Turin into a sprawling marketplace. This Flatiron location, the first in the US, opened in 2010 and quickly became a bustling hub where you can literally taste and shop your way through Italy. Regulars know to embrace the organized chaos, treating it less like a grocery store and more like a culinary adventure, often grabbing a glass of wine to sip while they browse.

★ The Legend
Tagliatelle alla Bolognese
This classic pasta dish features housemade tagliatelle, crafted fresh daily at Eataly's pasta counter, tossed in a rich pork and beef ragù alla Bolognese. It's consistently one of the most ordered and highly-rated dishes, praised for its authentic, comforting flavors that transport you straight to Emilia-Romagna.
◆ Fan Favorite
Cacio e Pepe
This classic Roman pasta dish is consistently praised for its rich, well-seasoned flavor and perfectly al dente pasta across multiple Eataly locations in NYC.
● Chef's Pick
Prime Rib Panino
This sandwich is a highlight at La Rosticceria, featuring succulent, sliced-to-order prime rib made with 100% Black Angus beef from Donley Ranch in Kansas. It's seasoned with a secret house-made porcini rub and served simply on a fresh baguette, a testament to quality ingredients speaking for themselves.
◇ Hidden Gem
Stracciatella (from the Mozzarella Lab)
Most first-timers walk past the Mozzarella Lab, but in-the-know diners seek out the freshly made stracciatella. You can watch the cheesemongers stretch and shred the cheese before it's drenched in heavy cream, and if you ask nicely, you might even get a sample.
Insider Tip

Don't just head straight to a sit-down restaurant. The real magic of Eataly is in exploring the marketplace. Grab a hand cart at the door, wander through the various counters like the fresh pasta or cheese sections, and assemble your own picnic to enjoy in nearby Madison Square Park. This way, you get to sample a wider variety of their incredible artisanal products and experience Eataly like a true local.

Every restaurant has its legendary dishes.

Find what to order anywhere →

AI-generated results — always verify dishes and information before visiting.