Steakhouse, American
Gage & Tollner
A feeling amplified by its status as New York's first landmarked dining room and only its third landmarked interior. The room itself is the star, with its original cherry-wood paneling, brass chandeliers, and mirrored walls, all lovingly restored. It's a place where the glow of the gas lamps (now electric, but still evoking the past) and the hum of conversation create an atmosphere of quiet confidence and timeless elegance, perfect for marking special occasions.
★ The Legend
Baked Alaska for Two
This iconic dessert is a dramatic tableside spectacle, featuring layers of fresh mint, dark chocolate, and Amarena cherry ice cream over a chocolate cookie crunch, all encased in toasted Swiss meringue. It's a showstopper that consistently earns rave reviews and is frequently cited as a highlight of the entire dining experience.
◆ Fan Favorite
She-Crab Soup
A rich and creamy Southern classic, this soup is made with blue crab and a generous splash of sherry, a nod to the restaurant's history and the influence of legendary chef Edna Lewis. It's a consistently praised starter that regulars often mention as a must-order.
● Chef's Pick
Clams Kimsino
Chef Sohui Kim's Korean heritage shines through in this dish, a playful take on clams casino. These 'little jewels' are topped with golden breadcrumbs tossed in a rich bacon and kimchi butter, offering a unique blend of classic steakhouse fare with a distinctive Korean twist.
◇ Hidden Gem
Parker House Rolls
While many come for the steaks and seafood, don't overlook these incredibly soft, buttery, and slightly sweet house-made rolls. They're often mentioned by regulars as surprisingly addictive and a perfect accompaniment to any meal, yet first-timers might pass them by.
Insider Tip
First-timers often focus solely on the steaks, but the real magic here is in embracing the full breadth of the menu, especially the seafood and classic cocktails. Start with a perfectly chilled martini and explore the oyster and clam preparations before diving into your main, as these dishes truly showcase the restaurant's historical roots and culinary finesse.
AI-generated results — always verify dishes and information before visiting.