Steakhouse
Keens Steakhouse
Keens isn't just a steakhouse; it's a living museum, famously housing over 50,000 clay smoking pipes, a tradition that began in the early 20th century when patrons would check their fragile pipes before dining. This enduring ritual, alongside its dark wood and Gilded Age prints, makes it the sole surviving establishment from the old Herald Square Theater District. Regulars often take a moment to scan the ceiling for pipes belonging to historical figures like Teddy Roosevelt or Babe Ruth, a quiet nod to the past before diving into their meal.
★ The Legend
Our Legendary Mutton Chop
The Mutton Chop has been Keens' signature dish for over 100 years, with the restaurant selling its one millionth mutton chop in 1935. It's a heavy bone-on cut of lamb (though historically mutton) that is carefully butchered and aged in-house from Colorado lamb, and is consistently highlighted by food critics and journalists as a must-try for its robust flavor and historical significance.
◆ Fan Favorite
Prime Rib of Beef, King's Cut
This enormous, bone-in prime rib is a true spectacle, often covering an entire dinner plate with its thick, rosy slab of marbled beef. It's consistently praised by regulars as one of the best prime ribs in the city, offering a rich, flavorful experience that can easily satisfy two or even three diners.
● Chef's Pick
Keens's Creamed Spinach
While many steakhouses offer creamed spinach, Keens' version is a classic, known for its rich, parmesan-forward profile without being overly creamy or sweet. It's a consistently recommended accompaniment to their meats, providing a comforting and earthy balance to the rich chops and steaks.
◇ Hidden Gem
Prime Rib Hash
Most first-timers walk right past this, but the prime rib hash, found on the pub menu, is a true insider's delight. It's a skillet-fried medley of potatoes, onions, and generous chunks of their famous prime rib, crisped on the outside and often topped with a fried egg, making it a perfect, hearty meal that many regulars enjoy at the bar.
✦ Off the Menu
Miss Keens Burger
This off-menu burger is a nod to the nude portrait hanging above the bar. It's a half-pound burger served 'nude' – without a bun – a perfect option for those looking for a lighter, yet still substantial, meal.
Insider Tip
First-timers often overlook the bar area, heading straight to their dining room table. Instead, arrive a bit early and grab a drink at the bar. Not only is it a fantastic spot to soak in the history and admire the 'Miss Keens' painting, but they also offer complimentary snacks like hard-boiled eggs and pretzels, and sometimes even rotating hot appetizers during happy hour. It's a great way to ease into the Keens experience before your main meal.
AI-generated results — always verify dishes and information before visiting.