Order this.
Order this.

Every restaurant has its legendary dishes. Find out exactly what to order.

Search a restaurant →
Doughnuts, Bakery

Peter Pan Donut & Pastry Shop

Greenpoint, Brooklyn, NY 📍 Maps

A true Greenpoint institution that's been serving up smiles since the 1950s. You'll find a classic S-shaped diner counter, often filled with regulars sipping coffee and chatting with the friendly, uniformed staff in their iconic green and pink outfits. It's a place where the community gathers, and the aroma of freshly baked doughnuts fills the air from early morning.

★ The Legend
Red Velvet Doughnut
This cake doughnut is a relatively newer addition to the menu, introduced by co-owner Donna Siafakas to offer new flavors alongside the classics. It's consistently cited as a best-seller and a must-try, known for its rich flavor and perfect texture.
◆ Fan Favorite
Boston Cream
The Boston Cream is a specialty donut that has been called the 'best donut' by some reviewers, with a luxurious, silky, and clean-tasting custard filling.
● Chef's Pick
Apple Fritter
This substantial pastry is a contribution from Christos Siafakas, the head baker and owner, known for his dedication to quality baked goods. It's a hearty, flavorful option that showcases the bakery's commitment to traditional recipes and generous portions.
◇ Hidden Gem
Egg, Cheese, and Meat Sandwich
While most first-timers flock to the doughnuts, regulars know that Peter Pan also serves up a fantastic breakfast sandwich. It's a substantial and satisfying meal that many locals swear by, often overlooked by those solely focused on the sweet treats.
Insider Tip

First-timers often make the mistake of only ordering doughnuts to go. Instead, grab a seat at the counter, even if there's a line, and order a coffee with your doughnut. This allows you to soak in the classic diner atmosphere and experience Peter Pan like a true local, often leading to friendly banter with the staff and other regulars.

Every restaurant has its legendary dishes.

Find what to order anywhere →

AI-generated results — always verify dishes and information before visiting.